I was talking to Alan Yu the other day - he used to run the GDC, now he's an A&R rep at EA - and we were talkng about the challenges facing the games industry today. He responded by describing his after work routine: picks up food on the way home, turns on the TV but mutes it to watch the ball game, plays music through his stereo, has a laptop nearby for communication and entertainment, and may also be talking on the cell phone to friends at the same time. What he was describing sounded like a multimedia nest, a coherent sensory and informational experience made up of modular and disparate pieces that coccoon him. Where does gaming fit into this?
Well, for people like Alan, it really doesn't. Why? Games require far too much attention - they demand input from our hands, processing from our brain, decision-making from the cerebral cortex. These days many games are so complex you can't even turn off their sound for fear of missing critical cues and clues. I admit that I am an inveterate multi-tasker - I play World of Warcraft while on AIM and sometimes as a TV show or film plays in the background. But it's hard to do and my friends lose me for bouts as I get pulled into combat. The set up is not ideal for a multimedia nester.
Of course, part of the appeal of games is that they are so profoundly immersive. We love to lose ourselves in other worlds like that - they are the ultimate engagement. And it sounds counter-intuitive, at first, to think that highly media-savvy and centered people want less engagement from their consumables. And yet - with no research to back up my claim - I think it might be true. Something important happens when one plays a game, something that can't be shared in the same space as other forms of entertainment. Games are like a black hole - you fall in and lose contact with the rest of the world. Sometimes, that's the exact feeling we seek; most often, though, we avoid it as a "time sink" precisely because we can't reasonably do other things at the same time.
Some applications have started to address this problem. Xbox Live does a pretty good job of allowing you to feel that you're still connected to the world. You can stream your own music while you play. When your friends come online, you know; if they leave you a message, you see it; and you can talk to them, even - with the advent of the Live camera - video chat, and still remain in the game. PS3 promises to deliver a similar integration of media and communications. In essence, what's really next-generation about these consoles is that they try to become your nest.
Another tactic is to turn this around - to allow consumers to take their media with them. That's the concept behind ubiquitous computing, the third wave of computing forecasted in 1988 by Mark Weiser. That's where mobiles and handhelds and DS Lites come in. But if we once again think of these experiences as layered on top of eachother, talking on the phone can be done safely while walking, while looking at other things, while eating, while reading the paper; playing a mobile game or texting is less easily layered on top of other experiences. Once again the depth of attention required gets in the way.
We're increasingly moving to a mode of media consumption that is layered; consumers dip into several media forms at once to concoct the perfect blend, to manage their own experience to be a balance of stimulus and reward and the attention required to recieve the reward. If games are going to survive, we need to figure out how they can contribute to the multimedia nest.
Another concept is gaming that's okay with waiting. While I wade through help desk tickets, I often have some turn based strategy running on a KVM'd pc, like Master of Orion 2 or Age of Wonders 2. They never mind if I'm away for 5m or 5 days. The DS is also great due to how easy it is to put a game on hold... you just close the lid. Heck of a lot more reliable than hoping the game creator put a good pause in.
Posted by: geedeck | 10/24/2006 at 02:06 PM
As someone who's about as media-savvy as one can get without a license, I have to disagree with the idea that the more plugged-in one is, the more broad one's focus becomes. From personal experience, I can say that I'm a serious single-tasker. Just hearing about Alan Yu's routine makes me edgy. Instead, I'd suggest that due to the way computers have been designed (desktop metaphor and all that), a lot of people who found computers to be a good fit for how they think became very plugged in. It probably drove lots of people who work more like I do away.
I say this as someone who cut his teeth on DOS and finds the whole desktop metaphor to be abhorrent. That's not to say I don't multi-task in a way: I switch between tasks, but probably less frequently by an order of magnitude than lots of people. I enjoy immersing myself in one thing. From what I can tell, it's something fairly basic in the way I think.
That deals with the determinism.
As for games that are less multi-layered, I certainly think there's a market for them. I think MMOGs address this market for some people, and for others, it's taken by Tamagochis or cell-phone games. Personally, I can't say I have much interest in that market. I'm interested in deeper experiences. I think a game where people want to mute it and turn on the radio (or a podcast) instead indicates that there isn't enough richness in the game's audio. It's a missed opportunity. Certainly, there's a place for games that are not so demanding, but I personally feel like I get enough superficiality as is.
Posted by: Ben Cummings | 10/24/2006 at 03:00 PM
As someone who's about as media-savvy as one can get without a license, I have to disagree with the idea that the more plugged-in one is, the more broad one's focus becomes. From personal experience, I can say that I'm a serious single-tasker. Just hearing about Alan Yu's routine makes me edgy. Instead, I'd suggest that due to the way computers have been designed (desktop metaphor and all that), a lot of people who found computers to be a good fit for how they think became very plugged in. It probably drove lots of people who work more like I do away.
I say this as someone who cut his teeth on DOS and finds the whole desktop metaphor to be abhorrent. That's not to say I don't multi-task in a way: I switch between tasks, but probably less frequently by an order of magnitude than lots of people. I enjoy immersing myself in one thing. From what I can tell, it's something fairly basic in the way I think.
That deals with the determinism.
As for games that are less multi-layered, I certainly think there's a market for them. I think MMOGs address this market for some people, and for others, it's taken by Tamagochis or cell-phone games. Personally, I can't say I have much interest in that market. I'm interested in deeper experiences. I think a game where people want to mute it and turn on the radio (or a podcast) instead indicates that there isn't enough richness in the game's audio. It's a missed opportunity. Certainly, there's a place for games that are not so demanding, but I personally feel like I get enough superficiality as is.
Posted by: Ben Cummings | 10/24/2006 at 03:08 PM
try multislacking with both WoW and the burning crusade beta running, and IMs coming in on three windows. now that's ummm, the inverse of nesting?
Posted by: eric | 10/25/2006 at 12:21 AM
I kinda feel the same way as Alan Yu. Everday, i log on to the web check out my usual 6 favourite gaming websites (Gamespot, 1Up, IGN, Kotaku, Joystiq, Destructoid), read all the news find out the latest info, check out the videos etc. & yet, when I go back home, I don't feel like playing video games off late. I don't know why, I mean I'm still interested in video games & the whole industry in general but some how I just lost the zest to play them.
Will the next gen consoles reinvigorate my interest...I dunno. We'll see.
Posted by: darkchild82 | 10/27/2006 at 02:36 AM
zertifizierung in Russlandexport
Certyfikacja w Rosji Certyfikacja w Rosji pozdrawia wszystkch
certyfikacja na wshodzienormy w Rosji
gost i Gostcertyfikacja GOST-R
Normy GOST i standardy certyfikat
certyfikat GOST
certification russia Russia
certyfikacja GOST-R gost
certyfikacja Rosja
wizy do Rosjito wszystko pomoze
Certyfikacja GOST ci prowadzic biznes w Rosji
certyfikacja GOST i wsem priwet
certificate of conformitygosty
russian certification gost
certification in russiar
russian certificationrosja
gost certificationw rosji
certyfikacja w rosjicertyfikat
gost certyfikacjacertyfikaty
certyfikacja na wschodzie
certyfikacja gost rrosja
certyfikacja w rosjiw rosji
gost r
russian certification
GOSTtest Gdansk
noclegi Gdasktest Gdask gost
gosttest certyfikacja w rosji
certyfikacja w Rosji w Rosji
zertifizierung GOST zertifizierung Russland
CERTIFIKACE RUSKO
certification russia
GOST ISO
gost zertifizierung
Noclegi gdansk pokoje goscinnetest Gdansk
gosttest certyfikacja w Rosji
Certyfikacja wyrobow i usug
certyfikacja w Rosjitest certyfikacja w Rosji
Certyfikacja wyrobow i usug
certyfikacja w Rosji gosttest certyfikacja w Rosji
Posted by: mik | 12/30/2006 at 10:48 PM